The Potential Sale of Our Building

 Nitzavim


Dear Rabbi,

If I were ever tempted to read a parshah from the Torah itself, it would be Nitzavim. For the most obvious of reasons, it is short and to the point. On a more important level, it includes some of the most fundamental principles of the Jewish faith. My comments today stem from these two observations.
 
In the very first words of the First Aliyah, Deuteronomy 29:9, it says the following:
 
“You are all standing this day before the Lord, your G-d the leaders of your tribes, your elders and your officers, every man of Israel”
 
In other words, we are all supposed to be as one, there is supposed to be unity among us.
 
In the Second Aliyah, Deuteronomy 29:13-14 we are told the following:
 

But not only with you am I making this covenant and this oath,”

“but with those standing here with us today before the Lord, our G-d, and [also] with those who are not here with us, this day.”

The covenant with G-d was not just with those that heard Moses’ words in the desert, but for all future generations.

Moses then goes on in the next couple of Aliyahs, to reiterate that we are not to stray from what is demanded of the Jewish people, but predicts it will happen anyway with dire consequences. He goes on to reassure the people that they will find their way back and that G-d will not forget them.

If we then skip to the seventh Aliyah, Deuteronomy 30:19-20, where it concludes with the following:

“This day, I call upon the heaven and the earth as witnesses [that I have warned] you: I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse. You shall choose life, so that you and your offspring will live;”

“To love the Lord your G-d, to listen to His voice, and to cleave to Him. For that is your life and the length of your days, to dwell on the land which the Lord swore to your forefathers to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob to give to them.”

Jews have the freedom of choice to choose between good and evil, life and death. Their choice will determine whether they are the beneficiaries of G‑d’s blessings or curses. Moses implores the Israelites to choose life.

The Jericho Jewish Center congregants will have the freedom to choose in the near future. Regardless of what they choose, the physical building will no longer be in the equation. The brick and mortar contained within the boundaries of 430 North Broadway, Jericho, NY was not what was meant when Moses told the people that they will “dwell on the land which the Lord swore to your forefathers…” Eretz Yisreal is the prize and all of the synagogues that have stood outside those borders face east to try and connect to what we are united with.

The congregants can chose “life” in the sense of carrying on the traditions we have established over the past sixty-five years by moving on or they can chose “death” and try to preserve something that is no longer sustainable.

Shalom,

Mordecai


Dear Mordecai,

This is a good parsha to read because it is so short, and I would love for you to read it some time. You must have read at your bar mitzvah. Do you remember the trope at all?
 
I struggle with this concept of unity, but one thing that has helped me of late is noting the distinction between unity and uniformity. Unity doesn’t mean we all think or act the same whereas uniformity does. Unity allows for dissent. Nevertheless, that dissent doesn’t lead to splintering and fracturing. We are supposed to be unified, absolutely, and our unity cannot just be unity in the face of enemies and opposition.
 
As for the second Aliyah, it does make me wonder. How can a group of people that is not present be inducted into an agreement, a covenant? Can that even work legally?
 
How do you reconcile the power of free choice with the insistence on obedience? That one freely chooses to be obedient seems to me a paradox. The choosing of life is critical to the Jewish way. Every Jew, no matter her level of knowledge knows the word “L’chayim!” Life is our chant, our call, our purpose. In fact – and I wish I could find the quote – I recall reading somewhere that Palestinian terrorists have declared that Jews love life too much. This is part of their death cult, and they think that our love of life will be our downfall. On the contrary, our love of life will ensure our victory over those who try to destroy us.
 
I appreciate you bringing the matter to brass tax, as they say. Yes, our congregation has a choice to make in the near future. I cheer you in clarifying for anyone who is paying attention that our synagogues in the Diaspora are important and functional, but they are not the purpose of our existence. Eretz Israel is. That cannot be stated strongly enough. The choice really is as stark as you put it: life in the consolidation or death in a storefront. To sustain ourselves, we have to graft on to a living organism – a synagogue – that is flourishing more than we are.  

Shalom,
Rabbi


Comments